Nigeria: Court Dismisses Copyright Claims Against Sinach Over Way Maker -

The Federal High Court has dismissed a copyright infringement lawsuit filed by music producer Michael Oluwole (Maye) against gospel singer Osinachi Joseph Egbu (Sinach) over ownership of the internationally acclaimed worship song Way Maker.

In Michael Oluwole v. Osinachi Joseph Egbu, the court rejected the plaintiff’s claims that he was a joint author and co-owner of the musical work and sound recording, bringing an end to a closely watched copyright dispute involving one of Nigeria’s most successful gospel songs.

Background of the Dispute

The suit, FHC/L/CS/402/2024, was filed before the Federal High Court, Lagos Division. Oluwole alleged that he made substantial creative contributions to Way Maker, including recording, mixing, mastering, and creating instrumental accompaniments such as the piano, strings, and synthesizers.

He argued that, because no written agreement governed their collaboration, he was entitled to be recognized as a joint author and co-owner of the work. He also claimed that his performer’s rights had been infringed and sought ₦5 billion in damages together with an equitable share of royalties, licensing income, and other proceeds generated by the song.

Sinach’s Defence

Sinach denied the allegations, maintaining that she was the sole author and copyright owner of Way Maker. She argued that the song had already been composed, arranged, and performed before Oluwole became involved and that his role was limited to providing studio engineering and mixing services, for which he was paid ₦150,000.

She further contended that the plaintiff’s contributions did not confer any copyright ownership, performer’s rights, or entitlement to publishing royalties.

Court’s Decision

After considering the evidence, the Federal High Court dismissed Oluwole’s claims, finding that he failed to establish entitlement to the declarations and reliefs sought against Sinach.

The judgment provides guidance on the distinction between technical production services and creative contributions capable of attracting copyright ownership. The decision also highlights the importance of clearly defining ownership rights through written agreements where multiple parties contribute to the creation or production of a musical work.

Author

Florence Akpotaire

Florence is a Media Content Specialist focused on reporting legal news, lawsuits, copyright infringement cases, and intellectual property developments. She is passionate about researching legal issues and presenting them in a clear, accessible way for readers.

Her work covers copyright disputes, trademark conflicts, court rulings, and regulatory actions across industries such as media, entertainment, technology, and business.

As part of the editorial team, Florence contributes well-researched and reliable content that helps readers stay informed about legal disputes and intellectual property matters.